Show me the decision.
Show me the working.
The cargo makes money. The cash does not arrive in time. Now what?
Open the report. Follow the cash. Change a condition. See exactly what the decision owner receives.

A report should change what you can do next.
A green dashboard does not tell Treasury which payment it can fund. A successful import does not tell Finance whether it can close. A full battery does not tell the trader which commitment it can honour.
IMPLEMENTARY works through the commercial and operating evidence behind those choices. The output is a usable decision: the options still open, the condition that changes the answer, the action an owner can approve, and the evidence another person can reproduce.
The profitable cargo with a funding gap
A $1m trading margin conceals a $1m facility shortfall. See the terms change that restores a $0.5m buffer.
Inspect the cash ledgerThe release that needs a smaller boundary
A normal quantity correction exposes a $28,500 invoice difference. See the replay, the control and the release decision.
Inspect the acceptance packThe battery offer that cannot be delivered
Twenty MWh looks sufficient until the first hour needs 11 MW. See the feasible offer and the revenue given up.
Inspect the commitment mapThe trade works.
The payment week does not.

The desk is considering a 1,000,000 MMBtu contractual gas cargo allocation. The all-in supplier payment is $10m. The customer owes $11m. Treasury has $11m of drawable capacity in the paying entity.
The initial request is to approve the trade. The decision becomes more specific when we put the supplier payment, collateral call and customer receipt on the same dated ledger. On day 8, the required draw reaches $12m. Profit does not settle that payment.
The useful job is to agree terms the entity can fund before commitment. A larger facility is one route. A customer advance is another. They need the same cash ledger and a clear commercial cost.
| Decision measure | Original terms | Customer advance | Larger facility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash capacity | $11.000m | $11.000m | $13.000m |
| Customer advance | $0 | $1.550m on day 0 | $0 |
| Concession / arrangement fee | $0 | $50,000 | $75,000 |
| Peak required draw | $12.000m | $10.500m | $12.075m |
| Minimum headroom | -$1.000m | $0.500m | $0.925m |
| Financing at 7% p.a. | $30,493 | $26,514 | $30,781 |
| Modelled contribution after fees and finance | $969,507 | $923,486 | $894,219 |
| Funding decision | Cannot commit on these terms | Meets $0.5m buffer, subject to receipt | Meets buffer, subject to signed facility |
Original terms exceed the $11m facility. Their contribution uses the same 7% funding rate for comparison; the route requires additional capacity before commitment. Contribution is before tax and overheads.
Negotiate a $1.55m advance and a $50,000 concession. Commit only after the advance has cleared and Treasury confirms $11m is drawable by the paying entity. This preserves the cargo allocation and the required $0.5m buffer. If either condition fails, return to the funding choice.
A smaller commercial change beats an unfunded approval.
The customer pays $1.55m earlier and $9.45m at settlement. That is the same $11m sale, not an extra receipt. After the $50,000 concession, the advance removes $1.5m from the peak draw.
The modelled contribution is $923,486. The larger-facility route produces $894,219 under its assumed fee and rate. The difference is $29,267; it is an option comparison, not an achieved saving.
Stop using lifetime margin as permission to pay.
Keep the actual delivery obligation and the entity funding boundary. Remove the assumption that a profitable contract is automatically financeable. Do not count a promised advance, group cash or an unsigned facility as available money.
The recommendation also has a limit. It leaves no headroom above the required buffer. A larger collateral call changes the answer immediately.

| Cash event | Original cash flow | Advance route cash flow | Advance route cumulative cash |
|---|---|---|---|
| D0: advance less concession | $0 | +$1,500,000 | +$1,500,000 |
| D1: all-in supplier payment | -$10,000,000 | -$10,000,000 | -$8,500,000 |
| D8: collateral | -$2,000,000 | -$2,000,000 | -$10,500,000 |
| D15: customer balance | +$11,000,000 | +$9,450,000 | -$1,050,000 |
| D20: collateral return | +$2,000,000 | +$2,000,000 | +$950,000 |
| D21: financing paid | -$30,493 | -$26,514 | +$923,486 |
Opening cash is zero. The facility is separate from cash receipts. Collateral returns in full and does not create profit. Supplier cost includes the allocated delivery costs. All settlements are USD in one entity; the example excludes FX, tax and hedge P&L.
Would you still approve it?
Move the advance or increase collateral. The original commitment and the $11m facility stay in the model.
Meets the $0.5m buffer. Confirm cleared funds and drawability before commitment.
A positive advance carries the fixed $50,000 concession. Interest accrues daily at 7% on the required closing draw and is paid on day 21. Same-day receipts must be cleared before payments.
| Challenge to agreed advance | Peak draw | Headroom | Decision consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collateral rises by $0.5m | $11.000m | $0.000m | Buffer is consumed; increase advance to $2.05m or reopen funding. |
| Advance arrives on day 9 | $12.050m | -$1.050m | Earlier breach remains; do not treat late cash as a cure. |
| Customer pays on day 22 | $10.500m | $0.500m | Peak unchanged; financing increases to $38,836. Check credit and delivery effects. |
| Revised advance for higher collateral | $10.500m | $0.500m | Buffer restored under the higher collateral assumption. |
| Decision record field | Populated instruction |
|---|---|
| Authority | Commercial owner agrees the concession; Treasury confirms the entity facility; delegated approver authorises commitment. |
| Evidence before approval | Signed sale variation, cleared advance, facility availability and settlement calendar. |
| Trigger to reopen | Collateral above $2m, advance not cleared by commitment, receipt date changes, or another trade consumes the facility. |
| Acceptance | A second analyst reproduces the $10.5m peak and the $0.5m minimum headroom from the cash ledger. |
| What remains open | Counterparty acceptance, credit limit and actual hedge/physical exposures require the client’s own evidence. |
The import passed.
The next event did not.

The team has reconciled the opening book. The decision is whether the intended first release can handle the business that follows it. We use a fixed-price refined copper sale, an ordinary quantity correction and a duplicate message to make that question observable.
The useful job is a bounded release decision with an operable exception route. A feature checklist or another green migration total will not show whether the invoice and ledger still agree after the correction.
Follow the quantity change into the invoice and receivable. Then send the duplicate and the late version. A release earns acceptance when the same economic result survives each event.

| Business record | Before correction | Required final state |
|---|---|---|
| Contract quantity | 1,000 t | 1,000 t |
| Delivered quantity | 995 t | 992 t |
| Remaining delivery obligation | 5 t | 8 t |
| Invoice / receivable | $9,452,500 | $9,424,000 |
| Ledger correction | None | Debit revenue adjustment $28,500; credit receivable $28,500 |
| Trace | Movement v1 | Movement v2 linked to v1 and the credit note |
This bridge isolates the sale, receivable and revenue adjustment. Inventory cost, hedging, taxes and purchase accounting are outside the fixture. The 8 t remain an obligation; they have not disappeared because the invoice changed.
| Test | Failure to expose | Economic difference | Required evidence after repair |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q01 Quantity correction | 995 t; AR $9,452,500 | $28,500 excess receivable; 3 t | 992 t; AR $9,424,000 |
| D01 Duplicate invoice event | Two balances; $18,848,000 | $9,424,000 duplicate receivable | One balance; $9,424,000 |
| V01 Late movement v1 | Reverts to 995 t | 3 t; $28,500 valuation basis | v1 rejected; v2 retained at 992 t |
| L01 Ledger acknowledgement fails | Marked complete; GL $9,452,500 | $28,500 AR-to-GL difference | Hold; replay credit note once; GL $9,424,000 |
Extend the same acceptance method across the release scope: products, volumes, entities, security roles, integrations and recovery requirements.
Keep automatic amendment posting out of the first release until Q01, D01, V01 and L01 pass with retained evidence. Permit a controlled first-release boundary only if Operations and Finance accept a two-person check for every in-scope movement. Any ledger mismatch stays open; it cannot be counted as a completed close item.
The event replay that earns the green status
| Arrival | Expected economic result |
|---|---|
| MOV-014 v1 | 995 t; invoice $9,452,500 |
| MOV-014 v2 | 992 t; net receivable $9,424,000 |
| Duplicate v2 | No change; duplicate recorded |
| Late v1 | No change; superseded version rejected |
Each accepted version replaces the movement quantity. It does not add another movement. A replay of the same backlog ends at the same quantity and receivable.
Price the temporary operating boundary
| Control input | Populated assumption |
|---|---|
| Daily in-scope movements | 16 |
| Two-person review effort | 6 combined person-minutes per movement |
| Allocated review capacity | 120 person-minutes per day |
| Daily workload / ceiling | 96 minutes / 20 movements |
| Ten-day control cost | $1,440 at $90 per person-hour |
| Targeted repair estimate | $7,200: 8 person-days at $900 |
| Modelled temporary route | $8,640 before software or supplier charges |
| Field | Instruction the operating team receives |
|---|---|
| Turn off for first release | Unattended amendment posting and automatic “complete” status when the ledger has not acknowledged the correction. |
| Keep visible | The corrected quantity, linked credit note, original invoice, event version and unresolved ledger exception. |
| Temporary owner | Operations checks movement identity and version; Finance reconciles the invoice and ledger; release sponsor owns the scope boundary. |
| Stop / escalate | More than 20 movements in a day, missing checker, unresolved material difference or review effort above 120 person-minutes. |
| Exit after ten business days | All four tests pass, backlog replay is idempotent, first-close reconciliation is reproduced, and the operating owner signs off. If not, renew explicitly or defer. |
| Decision alternatives | Full automation after evidenced repair; bounded release with the priced control; defer until the business can operate the scope. |
The energy balances.
The promises do not.

The battery has 10 MW of export capability and 20 MWh of usable AC-deliverable energy above its hard operating floor at 18:00. A firm sale already requires 6 MW in each of the next two hours. The proposed overlay is 5 MW followed by 3 MW.
Across the two hours, 12 MWh plus 8 MWh equals 20 MWh. In the first hour, however, the commitments add to 11 MW. Moving one MWh into the second hour solves the power conflict but still leaves no energy against the desk’s 1 MWh end reserve.
The useful job is to price the offer that can actually be delivered while protecting the existing sale. The original proposal is a comparison, not available revenue.

| Measure | Proposed overlay | Shift one MWh | Reserve-protected offer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Additional MW by hour | 5 / 3 | 4 / 4 | 4 / 3 |
| Total export MW by hour | 11 / 9 | 10 / 10 | 10 / 9 |
| Total delivered energy | 20 MWh | 20 MWh | 19 MWh |
| Ending usable energy | 0 MWh | 0 MWh | 1 MWh |
| Power limit satisfied? | No | Yes | Yes |
| 1 MWh end reserve satisfied? | No | No | Yes |
| Incremental economics | Proposed 5 / 3 | Shifted 4 / 4 | Accepted 4 / 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross revenue at A$300 / A$150 per MWh | A$1,950 | A$1,800 | A$1,650 |
| Energy and cycling cost at A$70 per MWh | A$560 | A$560 | A$490 |
| Contribution | A$1,390 | A$1,240 | A$1,160 |
| Executable under these constraints | No | No | Yes, subject to acceptance |
The executable offer forgoes A$300 of first-hour revenue and A$70 of variable cost compared with the impossible proposal: A$230 less indicated contribution. It preserves the firm 6 MW sale in both hours and the 1 MWh reserve.
The comparison uses A$300 / A$150 per MWh and A$70 per MWh of variable cost. Usable energy is defined on the AC export basis after discharge losses and the hard floor; the separate 1 MWh reserve is additional. No recharge, ancillary-service reservation, ramp constraint or outage is modelled. The existing firm sale’s revenue and costs are unchanged and excluded from the incremental comparison.
Offer 4 MW from 18:00 to 19:00 and 3 MW from 19:00 to 20:00. Do not commit the extra first-hour MW. The recommendation depends on both product volumes being divisible and the buyer accepting the revised shape.
| Decision field | Populated instruction |
|---|---|
| Before commitment | Confirm 20 MWh usable AC energy, 10 MW export availability, the existing 6 / 6 MW sale and acceptance of the 4 / 3 MW overlay. |
| Dispatch instruction | Hour 1: export 10 MW, leaving 10 MWh. Hour 2: export 9 MW, leaving the 1 MWh reserve. |
| If starting energy is 19 MWh | Reduce overlay to 4 / 2 MW to preserve the reserve; incremental contribution becomes A$1,080 at the same prices and costs. |
| If available export falls to 9 MW | Reduce first-hour overlay to 3 MW; 3 / 3 MW delivers 18 MWh and leaves 2 MWh; incremental contribution A$930. |
| If the buyer requires all eight MWh | Reject or renegotiate the proposal. Shifting the hour does not restore the reserve. |
| Acceptance | The dispatch owner reproduces the hourly power and energy balance and confirms no other commitment has reserved the same capacity. |
The customer receives the working,
not just the conclusion.
Bring the choice that is waiting, the date it matters and the records behind it. We work with your trading, risk, Treasury, Operations and technology owners to make the recommendation inspectable.
What has to change?
Agree the struggling moment, decision deadline and authority. In CARGO-01, the job is to fund the payment week while retaining the trade.
Show the actual obligation.
Retain the starting book and reconcile dates, quantities, versions and entity limits. Expose the exception that the summary conceals.
Compare feasible routes.
Change the smallest meaningful lever. Test cash timing, operating capacity or dispatch shape. Price what the change gives up.
Make it usable by the owner.
Deliver the populated report, source bridge, conditions, actions and reopening triggers. Require a second person to reproduce the result.
Two ways we help trading businesses decide
ETRM / CTRM advisory
Choose a system, a release boundary or a recovery route using trading events and operating evidence. The customer sees representative trades, expected results, observed differences, control costs and an acceptance decision.
Decision modelling
Compare a live commodity or energy trading choice against its existing obligations. The customer sees dated cash, physical constraints, alternative economics and the precise condition that changes the recommendation.
Scope and fees follow the decision and the evidence needed to resolve it. Client references are available privately where appropriate.
Take the report apart.
Take the decision reports and supporting tables into your own review. Follow the cash ledger, inspect the acceptance cases and compare the dispatch commitments.
Where the examples come from
These examples extend Implementary’s existing work on dated cargo funding, trading-event acceptance, migration, decision records and battery obligations. The cargo case adds financing, a paid concession, an explicit cash buffer and reopening tests. The release case adds a populated copper trade and deterministic event replay. The battery case adds the reserve constraint and the economics of the executable offer.
How to read the calculations
Cargo funding is the maximum negative cumulative cash balance. Interest uses the required end-of-day draw, 7% actual/365 and no interest on positive cash; payment occurs after the final modelled settlement. Facility breach is reported even when the model continues the contractual cash flows. The minimum headroom policy is $500,000. The release replay accepts a newer event version once, ignores a duplicate and rejects a superseded version. The battery calculation uses one-hour energy blocks with AC-deliverable energy already net of discharge losses.
Which decision is waiting
for evidence like this?
A funding condition. A release boundary. A commitment the desk is about to make.
Bring the decision date, the options still open and the records you already trust.
Explore a worked decision with us
