Trust but Verify: Vendor Oversight in Commodity & Energy Trading Systems

Best Practices for Oversight:

  • Set the Same Expectations as for Internal Teams: Treat the vendor as an extension of your own team. From day one, establish clear deliverables, quality standards, and timelines as if they were internal staff. Communicate these expectations openly so the vendor knows you will be monitoring outcomes.
  • Establish Verification Mechanisms: Put in place regular checkpoints to review progress. For example, schedule bi-weekly or monthly status reviews where the vendor must demo the latest functionality or submit progress reports. Require evidence-based updates (such as working software demonstrations, test results, or documentation) rather than just verbal assurances.
  • Conduct Audits and QA Testing: Incorporate independent quality assurance. This could mean having a third-party or an internal QA team test the system modules as they are delivered. Conduct code reviews or audits of configurations to ensure they meet your requirements. Remember, “trust but verify” means you believe the vendor is working hard, but you still double-check the work for compliance and quality. Vendors should prove they are meeting requirements through reporting, reviews and controls , just like your internal teams must.
  • Maintain Open Communication (Without Micromanaging): Keep a collaborative tone in oversight meetings. The goal is accountability, not adversarial oversight. Encourage the vendor to flag risks or issues early. When problems are found, work with them on solutions rather than merely policing. This balanced approach builds trust and keeps everyone accountable.
  • Interim Deliverables & Pilot Runs: Wherever possible, verify in stages. For example, if a certain module is due in 8 weeks, ask for an interim demo at 4 weeks to see progress. Doing a pilot or phased go-live can provide an early reality check on the system’s readiness. This incremental validation prevents nasty surprises at final delivery.
  • “Trust But Verify” Culture: By institutionalising this mantra, your team sends a clear signal: we trust our vendor’s expertise and intentions, but we will continuously verify outcomes against agreed standards. This culture ensures issues are caught early without breeding resentment. In fact, good vendors appreciate a client who is engaged and vigilant, because it increases the chances of project success.

Conclusion: 

By following these oversight practices, project sponsors gain assurance that vendor deliverables truly meet expectations. You can maintain a healthy partnership , trusting the vendor’s expertise and giving them room to work , while also implementing verification steps (audits, demos, third-party QA) to catch any gaps. This “trust but verify” approach creates a rhythm of accountability that keeps the project on track without infringing on the vendor’s autonomy, leading to a successful CTRM implementation.

About the Author

Jason Novobranec is Implementary’s Chief Operating Officer.

With over 20 years of Consulting, Program Management & Senior Leadership experience, Jason has delivered initiatives for large multi-national / multi-regional organisations as well as SME’s and is an expert in shaping solutions to fit a customer’s project needs.

Published On: August 27th, 2025 / Categories: Transformation /